STEAM 组
Sentinels of the Store StoreSents
STEAM 组
Sentinels of the Store StoreSents
214
游戏中
1,279
在线
成立于
2017 年 1 月 18 日
语言
英语
关于 Sentinels of the Store

It's Time for Real Change

The Sentinels of the Store is a group founded on the core values of transparency, fairness, and consumer protection. Our journey began when we saw the urgent need to address the growing concerns within the Steam ecosystem. Together, we formed the Sentinels of the Store to champion the rights of both consumers and developers, ensuring that everyone in our community is treated with the respect and fairness they deserve.

What We Stand For

We are unwavering in our mission to protect consumers from malpractice and deceit. Our commitment to transparency ensures that you can trust the games you purchase and the developers you support.

We believe in fostering a healthy environment where developers can thrive without fear of exploitation or unfair treatment. By advocating for fair enforcement of policies, we ensure that all developers, big or small, have an equal opportunity to succeed.

We take a firm stance against those who seek to undermine the integrity of the Steam platform. We actively work to identify and expose bad actors, ensuring that they face the consequences of their actions.

Consistency and fairness are at the heart of our approach. We strive to assist Valve in the enforcement of Steam's policies, making sure that rules are applied equally to all, without favoritism or bias.

Our Vision

We envision a Steam community where:

  • Consumers are protected and informed.
  • Developers are respected and supported.
  • Policies are clear, fair, and consistently enforced.
  • Transparency and accountability are the norms, not the exceptions.

We believe that real change is possible, but it requires the collective effort and support of each member of our community.

Together, we can build a better Steam community for all. Stand with us, and let’s make real change happen.

Part of the Sentinel Network

The Sentinel Network is a collective of Steam curators and advocacy groups dedicated to consumer transparency, ethical reviews & fair gaming practices.

If you value honest curation, ethical gaming, and protecting players from misinformation, please do join the groups that are part of the Sentinel Network.

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Check out our Linktree[linktr.ee]

Join our Discord server[discord.gg]

The Steam Sentinels Podcast

E-mail: mellowonline1@gmail.com

Group icon done by 2dengine
热门讨论
查看全部 (235)
近期公告
SteamWatch - Steam Enforces "Hidden Cats" Trademark - Indie Developers Forced to Rename or Risk Removal
NukeArts Didn't Invent the Genre

NukeArts weren't the originators of hidden object games featuring cats. Nor were they the only studio using the wording “Hidden Cats” or variations of it before the trademark was granted, nor were they the first ones to do so, even on Steam.

https://psteamproxy.yuanyoumao.com/app/1587560/100_hidden_cats/

One of the games that was forced to change their names even pre-dates NukeArts in "Hidden Cats" games.

https://psteamproxy.yuanyoumao.com/app/2907010/FIND_KITTENS_The_last_of_cats/

What they did was secure the registration first. The complaint submitted to Steam makes their intention clear. It doesn't simply argue that specific titles are confusing. It asks Steam to consider the registered mark when reviewing future game submissions that use “Hidden Cats” or similar phrasing as a dominant title element in the same genre.

One of the developers impacted kindly provided me the NukeArts complaint and you can find this below with only names redacted.

引用自 NukeArts' Complaint
ORIGINAL COMPLAINT

CONTENT BEING REPORTED

Hidden Cats? is a registered trademark of Nukearts Studio in the United States.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Reg. No. 7,968,484
Registered Sep. 30, 2025
CLASS 9: Downloadable video game software; Downloadable printable coloring books; Downloadable posters

ORIGINAL CONTENT

I am [REDACTED], CEO of Nukearts Studio, the developer and publisher of the Hidden Cats game franchise.

Nukearts Studio is the owner of the registered trademark “Hidden Cats”, with a valid trademark registration in the United States (USPTO), covering the products referenced herein.

We have consistently published games under the Hidden Cats franchise over the past several years, including Hidden Cats in Paris, Hidden Cats in New York, Hidden Cats in Rio de Janeiro, among others. These titles share a cohesive visual identity and branding that players directly associate with our studio.

We have recently identified multiple games on Steam whose titles begin with “Hidden Cats”, such as Hidden Cats: The Last of Cats, as well as titles that invert the wording, such as Cats Hidden Around the World. These games were released by unrelated developers after our franchise was established, operate within the same genre, and use nearly identical phrasing to our registered trademark. Use of the registered trademark HIDDEN CATS as a prefix or dominant element in similar products constitutes trademark infringement, regardless of suffix or subtitle.

There is clear evidence of marketplace confusion, including YouTube videos in which influencers mistakenly display our Hidden Cats branding or logos while showcasing these third-party games. This demonstrates that consumers are being misled and are likely to believe that these unrelated titles are part of our official franchise.

For these reasons, we believe these uses constitute trademark infringement and trademark dilution. We respectfully request that Valve review the titles listed below and take appropriate enforcement action in accordance with Steam’s intellectual property policies.

Additionally, we kindly request that Valve take this registered trademark into consideration when reviewing future game submissions that use “Hidden Cats” or confusingly similar variations as a dominant title element within the same genre.

Our intention is to prevent continued consumer confusion and repeated enforcement actions, and to ensure that our registered trademark rights are respected on the Steam platform going forward.

A complete list of the infringing titles and their corresponding Steam links is provided below.

Plaintiff

That isn't defensive brand protection in isolation. It's an attempt to control the naming conventions of a micro-genre on the largest PC marketplace in the world. It consolidates market visibility under one trademark holder. It restricts how competitors describe their own games. That is anti-competitive in practice, even if technically permissible under trademark law.

Steam's Enforcement

Steam issued a notice to developers, I've included this also in full below redacting names and the specific games to ensure the developer who forwarded this to me remains anonymous.

引用自 Steam
Hello,

We've received a trademark complaint from trademark holder [REDACTED] of Nukearts Studios against the following games:

[REDACTED] asserts your game titles infringe their IP in HIDDEN CATS. The trademark registration information can be viewed here:

https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=99016415&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch

https://branddb.wipo.int/en/similarname/results?sort=score%20desc&rows=120&asStructure=%7B%22_id%22:%22570c%22,%22boolean%22:%22AND%22,%22bricks%22:%5B%7B%22_id%22:%22570d%22,%22key%22:%22brandName%22,%22value%22:%22hidden%20cats%22,%22strategy%22:%22Simple%22%7D,%7B%22_id%22:%22570e%22,%22key%22:%22applicant%22,%22value%22:%22nukearts%22,%22strategy%22:%22Simple%22%7D%5D%7D&fg=_void_&_=1771453906318

Further, Nukearts has been continuously using HIDDEN CATS on Steam since at least 2022.

We know your games are important to you, so we ask that you change the infringing titles by the end of the day on March 2nd, 2026.

*The following game was not included in the trademark complaint. However, we're giving you a grace period to change all titles that infringe on [REDACTED]'s IP. Please be aware that if we receive a subsequent trademark complaint against the game, we will have to retire it from the store without a grace period:

Please note that the new titles may not contain both HIDDEN and CATS. You may use HIDDEN in your new title, or CATS. You can find more information on the game name editing process here: https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/store/editing/name

I've included the complaint at the end of this email. Please contact [REDACTED] directly with any questions regarding the use of their IP.

I'll check your games again on March 2nd, 2026. Please note that I will be out of the office from 2/22 through 2/28, so any email replies sent during this time will be answered on March 2nd.

Thank you,

Let’s be direct about what this means. The enforcement email was sent one day before the assigned Steam representative went on leave for the majority of the response window. The representative returns effectively on the eve of the deadline. Developers facing legal pressure were given a compliance deadline while their point of contact was unavailable for most of the window. Steam chose to structure enforcement this way. Steam didn't pause the deadline. Steam didn't assign an alternative contact. Steam didn't offer an internal mediation channel. Developers were told to comply or pursue legal action externally. For small studios, that isn't a balanced system.

Developers Are Complying - Because They Have No Real Alternative

Multiple developers were kind enough to share their experiences with me.

Developer Matt Roszak wrote to me:

引用自 Matt Roszak
I spent the next 48 hours quickly brainstorming some ideas and rebranding everything. It was a major inconvenience… Because my game was so close to launching, and participating in Next Fest, any sort of legal action I could take would just delay the launch for months, so there was little point in doing anything about it.

Travellin Cats wrote to me and explained the scale of the distribution:

引用自 Travellin Cats
It’s not just a title change. I have to change all the Steam capsules, trailers, backend stuff and the game builds themselves plus new code to not break existing saves etc. It’s been a huge undertaking to do this across around 20 app ids.

Their lawyer advised that challenging the trademark would likely be costly and uncertain. Travellin Cats concluded:

引用自 Travellin Cats
I choose to rename my games because Valve just complies. From my experience they don't listen to arguments so it would have been money thrown out of the window.

Even a developer who urged caution about publicity acknowledged that their own studio had been required to change its name. These are not developers celebrating a fair process. These are developers making rational economic decisions under pressure.

Challenging a trademark can cost tens of thousands. Renaming costs far less. Steam’s enforcement structure ensures that the cheaper path is surrender.

This Is Anti-Consumer

Players may not immediately feel the impact. Their purchased games remain playable. But the harm is real. When a genre-defining phrase becomes controlled property, search visibility consolidates. Discoverability narrows. Smaller studios lose descriptive clarity. Future developers avoid obvious genre naming. Market perception shifts toward a single trademark holder. Consumers lose clarity in search. Consumers lose diversity in branding. Consumers lose transparency in how genres are labelled. This isn't protecting consumers from confusion. It's restricting how competitors describe their own products in a shared genre space. That benefits one studio. It doesn't benefit the market.

Not All Developers Have Even Been Contacted

At least one developer has confirmed they haven't received any communication from Steam regarding a name change. The developer in question is a Chinese developer who released a series of Hidden Cats games in 2024.

This is a Net Negative

Let’s be clear. NukeArts didn't create the "Hidden Cats" micro-genre. They registered the phrase first.

Steam didn't create trademark law. But Steam chose how to enforce it.

The outcome is independent developers absorbing cost. Any legal challenge is priced out of reach. A descriptive genre phrase has been effectively consolidated. Consumers are losing clarity in discovery. Steam is structuring enforcement in a way that disadvantages smaller studios. The only clear beneficiary is the trademark holder. This is anti-competitive in effect. It's anti-developer in impact. It's anti-consumer in outcome.

If Steam's reputation is to mean anything, it can't simply default to procedural enforcement when the practical effect is market consolidation. This process is still ongoing. Developers are still renaming titles. The compliance window is still open. The imbalance is still playing out in real time. Steam can choose to be more than a passive conduit for market control. Whether it will remains to be seen.

If you wish to support the developers that are embattling this at the moment, please feel free to check out their games in the links below. Buy their games. Write them reviews. Leave your words of support and encouragement. If you're a developer who has also had to battle with these trademark enforcements, get in touch and I'll be happy to include you in the list below.

Travellin Cats
Matt Roszak
Gemcraft Games
cdhy interactive
Very Very LITTLE Studio

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Special thanks to our Patrons Stefan, Caff, old_Navy_twidget, Luke, Nin-Nin, emigrant, Pocket and Ismael Luque.

Check out our Linktree for our various pages![linktr.ee]

Join our Discord server.[discord.gg]

E-mail me: mellowonline1@gmail.com

Be sure to check out the other groups in the Sentinel Network:

Summit Reviews
Charity Games
Review Bomb Tracking
Games With Paid Reviews
Dr Chopper's Neuro Clinic

Let's Be Clear
查看全部 (774)
STEAM 鉴赏家
Sentinels of the Store 的评测
"Games by developers that have received coverage on our group, as well as identified asset flips and titles tied to anti-consumer/deceptive practices."
这些是 Sentinels of the Store 最近撰写的评测
1,709 条留言
Amberbaum 2 月 12 日 上午 3:22 
Thanks, Mellow!
Mellow_Online1 2 月 12 日 上午 3:12 
Hi @Amberbaum!

If your main concern is around the game’s anti-cheat system and what data may be transmitted when the game goes online, that would be better suited to the Fraudulent Activity / Scams sub-forum.

https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/groups/Sentinels_of_the_Store/discussions/22/

That section covers potential consumer-facing risks, including undisclosed data collection, intrusive software behaviour, or misleading implementation practices.

Appreciate you flagging it - just want to make sure it lands in the most appropriate section for visibility and discussion.
Amberbaum 2 月 12 日 上午 2:51 
It's not on itch, but I think it had an alpha test phase. Still, the reviews aren't even the worst. I'm more worried about their anti-cheat and what the game sends back to somewhere.
robilar5500 2 月 12 日 上午 2:45 
It's also worth considering that a lot of people will review games after an hour or two of gametime to make sure their reviews are the first ones posted. Typically, it was a means of points farming, and I think a lot of people haven't caught on to the fact that you can't points farm any longer, lol.

Then again, there could also be paid reviews. Just offering some alternatives that should be explored as well.
robilar5500 2 月 12 日 上午 2:42 
Was it previously made available to backers or on Itch.io or somesuch?
Amberbaum 2 月 12 日 上午 2:32 
https://psteamproxy.yuanyoumao.com/app/2966320/Starsand_Island/

Not sure if this is the right place to post it. Starsand Island has officially launched in early access. Their policies and anti-cheat are less then desirable. Game store got suddenly flooded by reviews after having no reviews. Reviewers barely played at all and say meaningless stuff in their reviews. Probably got pushed by the official discord to flood the store with positive reviews.

This thread in the forum is investigating what is being send and to whom when the game goes online. Start off from this marked comment and read further.


https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/app/2966320/discussions/0/762932162500560014/?ctp=14#c756177397086207505
查看全部 (4,380)
组成员
管理员
版主
214
游戏中
1,279
在线
253 聊天中
进入聊天室
成立于
2017 年 1 月 18 日
语言
英语