In my case, I fixed this issue by copying my spy_red.vtf from the tf_movies/ folder and replacing the spy_red.vtf I had in my usermod folder. The correct spy_red.vtf should have a grey rectangle in the top left corner over the mask.

godbless. ur the best person to exist

IT DID NOT WORK!!!!

What's wrong with the original texture?

for anyone wondering why this might not work later, but will work after resubscribing or something, here's why that "bug" occurs

it happens when your "workshop" folder has a higher priority than the "tf_movies" folder, and if you download almost anything that involves spy, you will get these weird hands.

The reason why this addon might stop working for you in the near future, is because, just like mentioned, you downloaded another item that replaces some VMT and VTF files for spy.

While this is surely a good fix if you need the workshop folder to be in a higher priority, it shouldn't be needed if your tf_movies folder has a higher priority. Hope that helps :)

For those that get the issue after being subbed for a while, unsub then resub, fixed it for me!

For the people who are lazy enough to restart their SFM, here's a quick tip:
Open the console and input "mat_reloadmaterial spy" (without the "").

Thank you so much, its been a pain trying to find out what was causing this.

same here, despite following the instructions it's still fucked up

The following GIF instructions don't work on my end.
What to do?

Thanks, alot. Before this i can only use the player model for the spy, and them low poly fingers bug the shit outta me......

tHANK YOU.

dat preview image...

For some people spy's hand texture is broken, and this fixes it.

Explanations?

It's like christmas morning

Thank you for this.
I'm now one step further into abandoning this FNaF OC...

This is a gift from heaven! Thnx!

Thank you so much for this