Seperated this from the comments section because it's was a bit lengthy.

The following is just an idea to try help you out with how you can implement kibble arrows without adding a ton of emgrams, etc.

Dev Kit process::
1. Pick out you want to save the settings per user, example :: add a per user setting actor (assuming you don't have one allready, and only have a global one for all the settings for the mod)

2. add 1 new arrow called "Kibble Arrow" :: setup this item that on use in inventory, it searches all of inventory for kibble bait, and applies it to the arrow (aka : acually applies it within the user setting). multiple use rotates through multiple kibble bait in your inventory as to what to apply to the arrow.

3. when you shoot that arrow, and it hits. on hit detection, the arrow checks for what the last kibble was that was set by that user (saved in a var within the user settings). Then it checks to make sure you have some of that kibble bait in your inventory. If you do, then it subtracts 1 from inventory, and place 1 in the world.

Optional :: you could add a check when the arrow weapon/arrow is being equipted to check if the bait is in your inventory at that point and give an message, to validate that kibble bait is still in your inventory and prevent firing without it, but having that check when hit would also be needed in case anyone removes it from there inventory between equipt and fire.