I would like to see a Portal 1 map port with original assets.

Something seems off seeing Portal 1 maps With Portal 2 textures. Yeah, It's too clean. Like original Portal had decals and overlays to show dirt and the textures were more dirty.

Very nice

THAT WAS AMAZING EVEN THOUGH I JUST PLAYED IT FOR 10 SECONDS

I feel like it's too clean...

this is now the best way to play portal 1 levels in vr!

@swtchickadeee my guess would be because its in portal 2 style, and it was so bright, thats just how it is

why is it so bright?

This is such a good project that I feel like I should report bugs. I didn't like this first one because of a few things:
- No timer above the autoportals
- No lamp on the ceiling at the start
- Radio is missing its red/green light and its radio transmission goal as well
- No 'emergency exit' in case players throw the cube inside the door (dialogue should play)
- A few Z-Fighting issues like on the wall of the last door to the elevator
- The first button was kinda clipping through its floor surface
I'll play the other ones now. Thank you so much for doing this, I've found it on youtube, it's a shame that the whole epic escape sequence is really hard to do, but you did enough!

I wonder if there would be an actual GLaDOS fight soon

it brings back the memories.. :)

Where it all started.

I like it

noice

and what number?

@valerka273 Where is it?

Couple of missaligned textures, weird lighting, definitely not using the P2 engine potential. The textures could use some variation. Auto-portals could really use some skins change in order to work like they do in P2 (Funcionality is helped by visuals, if the frame already has the color, it gives the impression that is bugged and, honestly... it looks bad.)


Nice try thou

I guess it's only a remake, but her voice lines could've been timed better.

Also, as of this comment, there are 2011 ratings. Portal 2 was released in 2011. Portal 3 confirmed.

There will be 2012 ratings and one more positive rating in 3... 2... 1.

Still unfixed :( Also, I found secret room in first chamber.

Like in original portal 1: bring radio to chamber, then use it to move cube outside.

@valerka273 How did you trap yourself?

I can trap myself in first chamber. Please, add reaction for this!

The map has been updated! The doors are now better cut out. Other bugs were also fixed. The title has been renamed to '' Portal 1 Remade '' because it's just a remade. The thumbnail has now been replaced with a real image. The following maps will also be updated in the near future.

Okay, but could have been better.

Great Remake! Looks Like Original Portal But Cleaner (Dirt-Wise)!

I'm sorry, but I have to be honest, this feels incredibly rushed. A lot of missing or wrong assets, shoddy work with ambient_generics, weird/ unnecessary brush work, average lighting, etc. The thing that disappoints me the most, though, is the clickbait thumbnail you've used. I knew what this picture was from before I even started... It's a screenshot from a Portal 2 mod called Alive and Kicking . This is utterly deceptive to players who don't know about that mod, and completely misrepresents your map. I'm sorry if this has upset you, but I can't help but feel that perhaps youv'e been a little too ambitious with this. Patience is a virtue, my friend.

Nice start!

This button is clipping through the brush below. Now trying to make an indent in this by yourself would be pretty tricky. Luckily, Valve have provided ready to use instances of the button sockets with the Portal 2 authoring tools.
This is just a nitpick, but these are Portal 1 fizzlers. It would be more in line with Portal 2's art style to use the Portal 2 fizzlers, as well as using glass lights instead of recessed lights.

I hope you found this review usefull for your future mapping endeavours, and I look forward to playing the next map in this!

PS: Sorry for posting multiple comments, but I had to due to Steam's 1000 character limit :p

These doors have weird frames around them. You should try to make sure the inside of the frame can't be seen through the doors. An easy way to make the frames would be to take a 128*128 brush, place a door model in it, and use the clipping tool to create horizontal cuts, and then make a single cut down the middle. You can then use the vertex manipulation tool to pull the vertices to the edges of the door to make a smoother circle. You may also turn this into an instance vmf file for easier use later with func_instance.

None of the observation windows have distorted glass.[/url] There are models for use with prop_static under the folder props_lab that are used for observation windows in Portal 2. Alternative, there are instance maps for use with func_instance of entire observation rooms to use. It would also look nicer if you had an env_projectedtexture in the large observation window, but that's just a minor detail.

I found this while looking for new Portal 2 maps to play. Looks interesting. I'll review each part as I play through.
Now, judging from you workshop articles, I guess this is one of your first maps made using Hammer. It looks very good considering that actually. However, there are some beginner mistakes. Most of them are probably easy to fix, or at least easy to learn how to fix.
The countdown timer textures doesn't work properly.
http://images.akamai.steamusercontent.com/ugc/94979010569234394/15A69EEBC1A6478F721D942C7F2343035AF3BC86/

Thanks!

@grim_prognosis fixed now

You can't solve this test without the third portal across from the exit in Chamber 2. Any chance this could be fixed please?

Around in the second area of the map, the Portal puts me into a black endless fall of nothing.

@Mandrew
That happened to me

The Portals are glitchy in test Chamb #2

Love the remake, now what I would like too see is good ol' radio transmitions, Chell's model and better voice recording for GLaDOS. Thanks!

the only thing i see that you need to fix is the player model its a stick figure right now try adding portal 1 chell or if that does not work portal 2 chell

@Simini W No problem Maaann

@spidery HD Thanks :)

Good one

@dven1 @DarkChili My Pleasure :D

Thank you for bringing back the memories :)

Nice map, well made and sufficiently lit. Nice redo, brings back memories. Thanks for your efforts.

YAYY

The new part is now online: http://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=874894663

@Spygineer Thanks :D

Well, It's not bad for an early map tho :p

@Spygineer I have intentionally taken the door from the 2nd part. It is supposed to be a remake. I'm still practicing cutting. I'm not so good at it.