congrats! it's a tough map. i'm glad that these reworks are giving people a good impression (and experience) of the classics. thanks for playing!

This is my new hardest solve, and it is also the best puzzle I've ever played in any game. There are simply so many creative and subtle moves in the whole sequence (losing and regaining access to the angled panel was amazing); every single step memorable, every element amazingly reused. Stellar map, and certainly my favorite portal puzzle.

excellent map!!! i did need a couple small hints. so great to see a red silencer collaboration. hey red what have you been up too?

unpossible

I think it's worth the sacrifice. I just prefer less connection IDK.

glad to hear that. this version mainly sacrifices its smaller layout for a reduced connection count. it's certainly interesting to compare the two. thanks for playing!

I like both versions oh my.

that entire convo was actually fascinating. wow

LOL

Your chamber sucked anyway... You uploaded an impossible one at the start... How stupid can you be... Hope the rest are like that too noob

you mentioned the ghost cube mechanic with no spoiler tags, which could give away a step
what "missing element" are you talking about? every time you voice your complaints you are so incredibly vague with your wording that i simply cannot work with it at all. at one point you were complaining about not being able to reverse the funnel fast enough, then at another point you were complaining about the cube being "messed up", whatever that even means? if youre not going to give workable advice and simply flood this comment section with the same ambiguous complaint worded differently every time, i'll just block you lol

Spoilers? There was no spoilers when I couldn't complete it the first time due to missing element that was not there when I played it.

twinzet im gonna delete that comment because it contains spoilers

thank you libby!

I got a chance to play this one. Great job on it!

TwinZet, my best guess based on all of your comments is that you do not understand the ghost cube mechanic. If my guess is correct, then this video might fill in the knowledge gap: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyk38-nIlqI . Hope that helps.

Thee solution video had the missing mechanic that was NOT in the version I played cause the cube was messed up. I know I'm right. Spki messed up the first time and ruined my first play through.

TwinZet, the map always worked fine. You misinterpreted your inability to solve the map as an indication that the map was unsolvable. You can subscribe to the map by hitting the big green [subscribe] button under the map pic on this page and the next time you start portal 2, the map will be in your queue for you to replay any time you like. You can also watch the video and see what the actual solution is. What you thought was the solution would have been a huge shortcut and is intentionally prevented. Have fun!

@Eric Northman, thanks for playing!
i published another update last night to polish up a few things and prevent a silly softlock. a solution video is now available on the map page (thanks RedSilencer for recording!)

nice puzzle, i like the updated version more than the old one , old one was good too but a lot harder to navigate

@TwinZet Even if you don't want to replay the map, there's now a solution video on this page, and by watching it you will see that everything in the solution was possible in the version you played.

So if you did fix it, it should be easier to beat it. But it was random chosen puzzle so i cant do it again.

ok

The version I played was not solvable. That’s all I know.
And I’m good at figuring out hard puzzles. So whatever version I played was messed up.

No but seriously great work! It was a nice 3 hours of solving

thank you harry! it was a lot of fun to watch you solve this very casual puzzle live

Nice easy one

SpKi why'd you make an impossible map?? smh my head

@TwinZet i am not the mapmaker but it sounds like you are approaching the map the wrong way.
Maybe you are in a similiar setup that does not make it possible yet to do what you are describing or the move you try to do isn't intended at all?
Knowing this mapmaker they certainly tested this map to hell and back and also had multiple playtesters so i doubt it is as impossible as you describe.
Please try it out again, you can always ask me for hints once i have solved the map.

the fix that the updates introduced was to prevent an exploit. if anything, the earlier version you played was EASIER because it allowed for a skip. also you still didnt answer my question if you watched the solution of the other version

The version I played was not possible to do... Cause i played it before you fixed it... So you messed up before posting it.

"you cant get all the way back to the starting point to reverse the tractor beam fast enough"? what are you referring to? did you watch the solution video for the other version? i play through my maps after publishing every update and it worked just fine. also, if we're going into detail, reminder to put spoiler tags when discussing

The version I played did not cause you cant get all the way back to the starting point to reverse the tractor beam fast enough... You clearly didn't test it correctly initially

map updated again to fix a timing issue. thank you mattchew for pointing it out.
@TwinZet i dont have a solution video of this up currently, but there exists one for RedSilencer's version (map linked in the description). you can cross reference that with this map if you wish, since the solution is pretty much the same. ALL versions of this that have been published so far have indeed been solvable!

Surreal to see this version uploaded after so long. Wonderful optimization of the OG puzzle, with great new sequences included. Love that both pistons block the laser now, so cool! Crazy how this puzzle is still getting remade 13 years later. Faved!

I must have been playing the version where it was impossible cause There was no way to complete the chamber at all... Bad on your end.

oh ok

heads up to everyone who subscribed early: i just had to update this map because i accidentally misplaced an invisible trigger. make sure to resubscribe if you have to!

welcome back rozen scale

fun map, probably like easy-medium tho (4/10)