Made a new discussion with full log copy

Failed to find Verse.RulePackDef named VSIE_Teaching_Toughness. There are 694 defs of this type loaded.

[Prepatcher, 0Harmony.dll] MonoMod.Utils.DynamicMethodDefinition.UnityEngine.StackTraceUtility.ExtractStackTrace_Patch1()
[Prepatcher, 0Harmony.dll] MonoMod.Utils.DynamicMethodDefinition.Verse.Log.Error_Patch10(System.String)
[Core, Assembly-CSharp.dll] Verse.DefDatabase`1[[Verse.RulePackDef, Assembly-CSharp, Version=1.6.9438.37837, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=null]].GetNamed(System.String defName, System.Boolean errorOnFail)
[Core, Assembly-CSharp.dll] Verse.RulePackDef.Named(System.String defName)
[Vanilla Social Interactions Expanded, VanillaSocialInteractionsExpanded.dll] VanillaSocialInteractionsExpanded.InteractionWorker_Teaching.Interacted(Verse.Pawn initiator, Verse.Pawn recipient, System.Collections.Generic.List`1[Verse.RulePackDef] extraSentencePacks, System.String& letterText, System.String& letterLabel, Verse.LetterDef& letterDef, Verse.LookTargets& lookTargets)

To clarify AAA's report a bit: Toughness skill throws an error when a pawn tires to teach another pawn about it. Will have to look out for that explicit error msg when I'm back in the game though.

Conflicts with Vanilla Social Interactions Expanded

@Inflamel I added it to work like all the other skills, so I think it should have decay. Mad Skillz is semi compatible aslong as you change the Toughness skill strength settings

Does the toughness skill suffer from skill decay? and if yes can that be remedied with the "Mad Skills" mod?

This not needing Hugslib would be swell

I'll try and do that; thank you.

@Nameless Keeper

have you tried turning on the debug mode and checking the logs? when a pawn takes damage, it should break it down

Anyone else having a problem where the skill does not decrease incoming damage?

Omg I got so scared when the 1.5 version was removed. Glad there is a github.

I hope future authors really take care not to remove old versions so needlessly to not brick people's saves.

@爱生活爱自己
The mod is trying to apply a change (via "PatchOperationAdd") to "IncomingDamageFactor"
It's using /Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor" and not(parts)] to target that stat- but the game couldn't locate or match any XML node that fits this exact description.
It's not a crash, but the toughness skill won't affect damage resistance in some way, either leveling it does nothing or the increased damage taken from Toughness lvl 0 isn't applying properly.

This is a v1.6 mod, make sure you're on v1.6. Might work in other versions, might not, your risk to take.
Combat Extended or other mods that affect damage resistance in some way could conflict, breaking the selector and disabling the mod with the lowest load priority, so swap load orders and see if it works.

Need more info if you want real help.

[Toughness Skill- Start of stack trace]
Verse.PatchOoerationAddixoath-"Defs/StatDef[defName-"IncomingDamageFactor" and notipartsl"): Failed to find a node with the given xDath
] [Toughness Skill] Patch operation Verse.
AddrL
[Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor" and not(parts)]) failed
file:E:\sTEAM'steamaDDs\workshop'content\294100\3448693012\Patches'IncomingDamageFactor.xml

@тетеря, блин does this do anything that you can tell or is it mostly safe rn?

maybe there's some incompatibility with «VSIE - Rational Trait Development»:

– https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2916405546

https://gist.github.com/HugsLibRecordKeeper/65087b43db3585f541d56e347ec88eb7

Failed to find Verse.RulePackDef named VSIE_Teaching_Toughness. There are 667 defs of this type loaded.
UnityEngine.StackTraceUtility:ExtractStackTrace ()

hugslib isnt that much bloat, just download it

YESYESYES

any chance of getting aversion without hugslib?

Getting this error when people try to teach me about toughness(also causes an error with Interaction Bubbles.):

Failed to find Verse.RulePackDef named PawnEducation_Toughness. There are 521 defs of this type loaded.

[Harmony, 0Harmony.dll] MonoMod.Utils.DynamicMethodDefinition.UnityEngine.StackTraceUtility.ExtractStackTrace_Patch1()
[Harmony, 0Harmony.dll] MonoMod.Utils.DynamicMethodDefinition.Verse.Log.Error_Patch3(System.String)
[Core, Assembly-CSharp.dll] Verse.DefDatabase`1[[Verse.RulePackDef, Assembly-CSharp, Version=1.6.9348.31746, Culture=neutral, PublicKeyToken=null]].GetNamed(System.String defName, System.Boolean errorOnFail)
[Core, Assembly-CSharp.dll] Verse.RulePackDef.Named(System.String defName)
[Pawn Education (Continued), RimWorld_PawnEducation.dll] PawnEducation.InteractionWorker_Education.loadSkillBasedSentences(System.Collections.Generic.List`1[Verse.RulePackDef] extraSentencePacks)
[Pawn Education (Continued), RimWorld_PawnEducation.dll]

are there any plans for traits to give a boost to this in the future? like tough giving maybe a +10 Toughness rather than giving a 50% damage negation?

I still had the error after uninstalling Rimworld, all mods, and all config data

for anyone with the below errors, try deleting the folder from your downloaded workshop mods and resub to the mod.

For anyone wondering how zzzdragon25 fixed it, I think this is a correct way to write the IncomingDamageFactor patch.

<Steam>\steamapps\workshop\content\294100\3448693012\Patches\IncomingDamageFactor.xml

<Patch>
<!-- Operation 1: If no <parts> node exists, create one with your entry -->
<Operation Class="PatchOperationConditional">
<xpath>Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor"]/parts</xpath>
<nomatch Class="PatchOperationAdd">
<xpath>Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor"]</xpath>
<value>
<parts/>
</value>
</nomatch>
</Operation>

<Operation Class="PatchOperationAdd">
<xpath>Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor"]/parts</xpath>
<value>
<li Class="ToughnessSkillMod.StatPart_ToughnessDamage"/>
</value>
</Operation>
</Patch>

Same error as Eze and zzzdragon25.

If you don't mind me suggesting expertise ideas: stagger resistance, a (small) amount of natural armor, healing factor (similar to ghouls but like 1 point / skill level / day rather than 300), or fire/toxic/vacuum/rot resistance. Cheers!

OMG I have wanted a mod like this forever, rpg level up mods felt too gamey but this looks perfect!

another humanoid alien race that doesn't gain toughness skill with damage is synstructs

After some testing inside game i get now also error in the menu:

[Toughness Skill] Patch operation Verse.PatchOperationAdd(Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor" and not(parts)]) failed
file: D:\Steam\steamapps\workshop\content\294100\3448693012\Patches\IncomingDamageFactor.xml

Anyway great mode, love it!!:)

Basically a trait from kenshi, neat!

Red error while start up

[Toughness Skill - Start of stack trace]
Verse.PatchOperationAdd(xpath="Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor" and not(parts)]"): Failed to find a node with the given xpath

[Toughness Skill] Patch operation Verse.PatchOperationAdd(Defs/StatDef[defName="IncomingDamageFactor" and not(parts)]) failed

It looks like patch imcompatibility of IncomingDamageFactor

I modified IncomingDamageFactor.xml with <Operation Class="PatchOperationConditional"> and it works fine so far.

Humanoid Alien race has the 'Toughness' skill, but cannot gain experience points for it.

Working for Vanilla Races,but not working for Humanoid Alien race ,such as kiiro ,Miho,Gloomy Dragonian race

it works,thank you very much.

in rimhud settings, i made a preset that adds it. just choose that one

my toughness does not reflect on rimhud while i have placed it in the end

not connected to endless growth yet?

Thank you for the update, now we can balance it on our own and hopefully get it working with endless growth

very underrated mod I love it.
I think it does a good combo with Combat skills matter more by improving the combat experience but not being simple too.

Could you add pain shock threshold to this, please?

bro why did you make 1.5 in github? you can have multiple versions on steam. Also why the dependency?

Thanks for suddenly adding a dependency on HugsLib without any warning. I had to waste almost an hour figuring out why my game wouldn't even launch

Beyond the error in the error log, does the incompatibility with VSE do anything? Particularly in relation to performance is my concern.

Similar to this mod, it would be nice to have a mod for movement speed skill.

does it support options? I'd love to make it subtle.

uhh for me it still say 1.5 in game and says incompatible every time i try to enable it resulting in all of my mods being disabled

where's the 1.5 version?

why remove 1.5 tho?

@Arch_ its out already lol

im already feinding for 1.6

why did u remove the 1.5 tag...