Out of curiosity, is this still not compatible with AGOT mod?

Noticing a similar issue as @Microsoft Excel 2007

Will this work in both 1.16 and 1.17 like some other mods will?

Seems like it got conflict with princess of darkness or better battles (updated) mods, after recent update. Cause crashes during loading screen.
Doesnt happened before update.

Commander traits seem to not be gaining any XP after winning battles. A guy i put in command of my army won 3 battles in a row and all his traits are still at 0 xp. Also most other AI are still at level 0 in all commander traits with 0 xp, some have like 20 xp.

@bobothechimp22 hi nope it does not modify stats in any way, it must be coming from another mod. I just tested on my end and the limit is still 100

does this mod max out stats at 25? ive started using this mod but now all characters are maxed at 25 instead of 100

I have translated your mod into German (AI assisted) and added the localization to my translation mod: https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3355568022
Of course, you can extract the files and add them to your own mod, or include a link to the mod in your description — or do neither. As you wish! ☺︎

@CarnageisChaos here you go :
mapper
observant_pathfinder
respected_leader
sea_raider
seasoned_rover
resolute_localist
relentless_pursuer
infiltration_specialist
battlefield_medic
dauntless_leader
crafty_commander
cautious_planner
bannerlord
focus_specialist
master_ambusher
navigator
zealot
patriot
military_savior
combined_arms
levies_specialist
skirmishers_specialist
archers_specialist
heavy_cav_specialist
light_cav_specialist
heavy_infantry_specialist
archer_cav_specialist
pikemen_specialist
knights_specialist

Hey, what are the cosnole commands for adding each of your traits? I've figured out a few but some still elude me and i would be very appreciative if there was a doc with all of the listed out.

@shredinboy it's a pleasure ;)

@The Desert Fox Hi mate can you be more specific ? ^^

@Sir Full Truie
Is this still not compatible with commanders.

This is easily one of the coolest mods in CK3, I really appreciate the work you continuously put into it, thank you!

@buzina hi sir, because it takes times to translate in all languages even with AI help (as it's bat at knowing how to handle tokens and messes up sentence structure) and I'm working on another mod atm, i'll do the translations once i've finished ;)
Of all the languages the game is available in, the two i speak fluently are English & French, so i was able to make those right off the bat

tl, dr, it'll come back no worries

Good day. Can you tell me, after the last update, part of the description text stopped being displayed in Russian. Why did this happen?

Where update ??

@alexcb1607 spanish loc update will come, but i've remade descriptions from scratch so for now it's in english

@alexcb1607 hi this will be done through the next update ;)

Hi. First of all, thanks for the mod, I like it too much. But, the spanish translation is not compleate, there are some traits that dont have a spanish translation and I was wonder if you are thinking on cover this situation. Thanks again for this mod.

Hello Truie; Thank you for the work on the mod, it makes the gameplay more enjoyable. I really appreciate the work you put into these. Thank you.

@emoleak24 mmmmh the error still belongs to the mod though
however yes, it's not the cause of the crash
thx 4 sharing the logs

Nvm, seem like this is a vanilla bug in the new patch

Hello, can you tell me about this error:

[18:12:15][E][jomini_script_system.cpp:284]: Script system error!
Error: Could not fetch title or province from scope 'county'
Script location: file: events/lifestyles/cmd_commander_events.txt line: 24 (fow_trait.0001:immediate)

[18:12:15][E][jomini_script_system.cpp:284]: Script system error!
Error: Event target link 'county' returned an unset scope
Script location: file: events/lifestyles/cmd_commander_events.txt line: 24 (fow_trait.0001:immediate)

[18:12:15][E][jomini_script_system.cpp:284]: Script system error!
Error: Invalid left side during comparison 'holder'
Script location: file: events/lifestyles/cmd_commander_events.txt line: 24 (fow_trait.0001:immediate)

I am having a CTD and this error is the last in error.log. I think it's incompatible with some other mod or something.

Anyone been able to make a AGOT comp?

@牛奶大魔王 sure thing, thanks

@Silvertax hi, how so precisely ? could you share the logs / error files ?

Hi, just a heads-up: your mod appears to be incompatible with multiplayer. We conducted a test in a clean environment using only your mod, and experienced issues when attempting to connect in multiplayer. It would be helpful to mention this limitation in the mod description.

Greeting! A great mod, but the Chinese tran had some weird maybe use machine translation, so I've retranslated the new Chinese loc inside CK3 mod Chinese loc mod,

would u make a line in description?

here's my Chinese translation:
https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=3403925213

@Khada_Djin laright thanks for doing it mate, i'll test it on my end extensively
be patient i have a lot to do ahah

After extensive research i can say that in vanilla game with only Commanders+ installed i am still not getting any traits from this mod

Author held me at gunpoint and threatened me if I didn’t install their mod

@Khada_Djin please boot up a game without PoD and see if you still have an issue
i'd suspect some incompatibility of some sort

Hello, i am playing this mod alongside Princes of Darkness and literally every other ruler and commander are getting new commander traits except me, any idea why that is?

I think I prefer the previous trait upgrades

Thank you for the update ^^

"Hell, It's about time." - John Starcraft

Updated, we're so back

@Darkwing Phoenix yeas I will remove vanilla traits from the mod ofc
Dread base might be doable, though requires quite the workarounds, plus ther is already knight effectiveness per dread, will see
Trait based on MA types unfortunately don't apply to the commanders' army, but to the character's faction MAAs, trust me, I had tried in the past ^^
But I have some ideas, no worries
Rebalancing, and some new stuff
I'll try to make the mod as update proof as I can, it had gotten spaghetti-esque

My ideas:

1. Just remove all of the vanilla traits from this mod. Now that they're in the game without mods I feel they're obsolete in mods (Unless said mods change the art or affect how often they appear/don't appear)
2. Add a trait involving Dread like @Daedalus93 suggested, potentially making your troops tougher and removing enemy advantage (The added toughness would be from troops being too scared to desert your side)
3. Traits based on each MAA type, gaining XP whenever you win battles with said troop type (Use a lotta Heavy Cav? You get a trait that makes your Heavy Cav better), allowing for specialization

Maybe one based on dread? I’m not sure what it would be called or how it would work on a technical level but basically it would be an attempt to replicate the reputation of someone like Tamerlane or Vlad the impaler where a lot of rank and file troops would rather desert than face them

@all
https://forms.gle/YbAjCNfYyCLMh57PA hey guys if you wanna give your opinion on the traits the mod adds for the upcoming update, the idea is to have feedback for balancing purposes

@Tygrtraxx I'll be revamping this one since commander trait tracks are now vanilla when I'll upload it
I'll wait for Steppes tho, I'm only updating lightweight mods for the time being ;) thanks for the feedback ! :)

Mainly "Duplicate localization key." which is easily ignorable since it's just cosmetic, "Inconsistent effect/trigger scopes (combat_side vs. character)", which will likely cause bugs, "add_character_modifier (insert_modifier_here) doesn't match expected type 'character', another one likely to cause bugs or issues and quite a few more.

Most of it is just syntax which just needs to be slightly changed or tweaked. It's just that there is a lot of it. I'm gonna throw a random guess out here, but your game might also be falling back onto vanilla values for certain traits because of syntax changes and the introduction of tiered base traits in 1.15.

But hey, if it's 100% working, maybe I'm just unlucky and have some sort of lemon somewhere. Only started having issues when 1.15 dropped. 1.12.5 - 1.14.3 was smooth as butter.

That's why I have a lot of respect for authors like @I Am Full Truie, glad to hear he's gonna be releasing an update in Steppes, looking forward to it :).

@monnoboy Yeah, after going through the code to understand it, the CTD's were coming from another mod (I highly suspect the Unofficial Patch Mod), since I did a full reinstall/wipe of all cache/files/mods of the game. But they're always hard to track down with limited tools that they provide us. I'm surprised you didn't notice any errors in the error logs. I just started a game up, no mods, only Commanders+ and declared war, let it run for a few months and still got some to spit out plenty into the error log.

Still works fine for me as of 4/11/25. No crashes or bugs encountered on my part even with my other 33 mods installed.

Tx

I will, when Khans of the Steppe is released.

update

Update?