Terraria

A war paint that doesn't make your eyes catch fire. I'm not usually a fan of repeating patterns with plastered PNGs all over but the subtle colors really compliment that aspect of it. I think you could potentially constrast the textures further but even as it is I wouldn't mind having this in game, good work.

Kinda bland but not the worst. A yes from me

too shallow

This is how sticker warpaints should be done. It looks like the leaves were all painted or drawn on individually to create a pattern, and the leaves are drawn in such a way that it looks as if the pattern is flowing in a certain direction rather than being held in place. Combined with the leaves being uniquely placed, the whole pattern feels really genuine and stylish despite appearing as simple.
This does lead to it looking a bit iffy on some weapons, but overall I think this is nicely done.