Good map. I r8 4.95/5 coz of unfinished feeling (not the map itself but scenario) and weapons "old". But anyway it's good. Gameplay is probably around best not annoying which i like.

Today I passed this mod. I want to say that there are original ideas that surprised me. I liked. I hope the author didn't abandon the hammer)

Very nice map! I had a lot of fun with it.Very good gameplay, and posed a good challenge. Especially the end part was really cool, with the Transit system. Great job!

Extremely nice map!

verry verry Cool :-)
THX for creating !!!!

This is a fantastic little level you've made here, it's a travesty they ranked you 9th in the Escape from Black Mesa contest!

Really unique map design, and a fun gameplay experience. 40 minutes of fun. I highly suggest playing this if you're hungry for Half Life content.

Well thought out, the weapon selection is balanced, the ammo count not too plentiful nor missing.
Felt pretty standard to the original, 8/10!

I really liked the map design. It felt like it was well thought out

Great work!

If nothing helps try to uninstall the game, remove all remaining files in "steamapps/common/Black Mesa" directory and install the game again. It usually helps (with other maps/mods as well).

crash at start

this is fuckin awesome

pretty neat

Loved it

COOL

интересная и захватывающая карта

Extremely fun map! Really love all the HECU vs Xen combat going on some some parts of the map.

The ambush near the end/beginning area felt kind of unfair because there was barely any cover and no medkits.

Neat mod. I might replay it a few times, cause it could really pass for a proper level. Although I would say the final section needs some more medkits, I had to dash to the reception area filled with health to avoid dying.

Very good overall. My only criticism is that the final, combat heavy section could have used with some more health, and perhaps allowing the player to explore the final arena a bit before the fight begins would have been good. I had to camp the office and desperately try to heal because I was down to 25 and no armor when it started. A medkit on the tram wouldn't go amiss either.

Damn, this is an excelent map! Very well designed and paced!

Very good map, maybe it would have enhanced the horror/survival aspect if you had access to less weapons and less ammo.

Cool but map crashes the game right after getting the crossbow for some reason.

Epic! 10/10

this is a really cool map. love how it progresses. and the ending is fantastic

Very nice map, it is nice how you can see your exit at the beginning.
Walkthrough: https://youtu.be/xiVp-tAkcZY

Very fun, loved the used of flooding throughout, thank you for sharing your creation with us!

Really good map, In the spririt of the original game ! Thank You !

Awesome map! I love the map design. I like that I can easily figure out what should I do to open the paths.

Short, but fun!

Pretty decent map, didn't really have any issues with it, I really liked that the starting area turned out to be our escape route

Great map, but too tough and needs more health. When i get killed 2 times, my game crashes. Uninstalling this map and dislike, CAN YOU PLZ FIX THIS MAP AND ADD MORE HEALTH!?

A very good map. Frustrating, but in a good way..

This map is the best, Good map editing and nice lighting

Awesome! Love the revisiting of all the areas.

It's so freaking good! Props to TRIGGER_HURT, you created a masterpiece!

This is AWESOME!!! That's a kind of Half-Life adventure I always wanted ))) many thanks for your efforts and your work

I swear this mod needs a part 2

this mod is a blast

This map is near perfection. I replayed it a few times to get a no-death run. I felt like I was taken back to the 90s when I first played Half-Life. The section with ladders and vents was a bit tedious, but the overall execution was fantastic. I'm hoping there will be more maps of this quality in the future.

I was able to run it by executing "map lb_comp3_fluid_logistics" in the developer console

How to run this map? I cant find it in the Black Mesa ingame Workshop - i also cant open it with the console with the map name "lb_comp3_fluid_logistics"

This is the best map in the competition so far, good job!

Excellent overall. Quite a journey. Close to release quality if only slightly let down by the swimming "up and down" section which really pushes the limits of breathing time too far.

If I had one gameplay criticism, it would be that the puzzle aspect was a bit weaker in comparison to the rest. I was disappointed that the 2 pumping stations involved merely pressing a button to solve the entire premise of the map. That was a missed opportunity. I think the puzzles you did earlier on in the map were alright, but repeated a little, and didn't really go anywhere either. Furthermore, I also agree with Kralich that the vent section jumping from ladder to ladder was awkward. I died once or twice there because of the fiddly controls. It's a shame because I actually loved that section in spite of that.

Visually, this map was really strong too. Great use of lighting and theme throughout, and the water sections certainly felt horrifying in their own unique way! One visual criticism would be to play up the horror more somehow. The map was combat-heavy, and there wasn't anything that entirely fit the theme of this contest.

Overall, this was a really great entry! Amazing work.

(I'm Chon, Lead Level Designer at Crowbar Collective and a judge for the competition!)

I thoroughly enjoyed this entry! You somehow achieved the impossible and made a really fun water-based map!

The way you synced several different area themes together in a cohesive way was really impressive. OaR/AM/some of your own ideas. The map had a mix of interesting navigation/traversal, as well as strong combat overall and some nice puzzles. I loved the way I looped around and revisited some of the environments and you got a lot of use out of all your cool spaces. I loved the creative re-use of different BM themes and ideas. I LOVED the OaR tram section, and I was delighted by your clever re-use of the river from dm_undertow! The map kept throwing new and cool things at me, and I was totally here for it.

(Hey there - I'm Kralich, the organisation lead for this competition. I'll be leaving a little paragraph on each entry with my notes and opinion in lieu of posting on Discord given the nature of this competition.)

JUDGE'S NOTES: A phenomenal entry with great gameplay variety, memorable vistas, and a core hook that you run with all the way. Telegraphing was solid; visuals ranged from great to gorgeous; and all in all this was a lovely map. The only caveat was that ladder section - interesting in premise, awkward in execution, and it stands out like a sore thumb compared to the diamond-sharp refinement present in the rest of the map. I have to really reach for that gripe especially when all of the positives are taken into account. I was also pleasantly surprised to see the crossbow, which has been a very underutilised weapon throughout all the entries in the competition. Great work!

One of the best ones, however I always lothe when i'm forced to use the on rail cart in any context, and the encounters could be harder, I was always flush with bow/magnum/shotgun/nade launcher ammo

Very good map.
Game design is old-school in places, in the style of old games on the source (mine and technical corridors along the tunnels), which is good.
Atmospheric mine and train ride.
The gameplay is spectacular and keeps you in suspense.