Why is it on first page

Why not multiple effects, each with different colour ghosts? I think that would also let it have more ghosts without it making it look too much worse.

Only really issue I have is the Gravestone png, the ghost effect and the smoke is pretty well done, but it's just so out of place compared to the rest of the effect.

It looks great already, but like other people have said, team colored would be better.

i agree that ghosts should be team colored, if they would, i think this would be a nice unusual effect

Yeah I agree with the few others here who say to make the ghosts team-colored and less saturated. I think a good in-game paint color to look at would be "Waterlogged Lab Coat":
— RED: #A89A8C
— BLU: #839FA3

I think the ghosts are unnecessary and too colourful. They should be one colour or maybe have them team-coloured.

But I like the grave and the fog around it. This is a decent unusual effect.

Scientology

Thanks for the input guys, it's appreciated a ton!

Why does the youtube video need to assault my ears with bass

The gravestone is my biggest criticism with this. It literally looks like clipart and isnt stylized towards the tf2 style at all. The ghosts look passable but they feel like they’re from another game. Concept is decent overall, the design of those two objects just need to be reworked.

This looks nice! If I had one thing I'd like to see different, it's to have the ghosts either be a single neutral color (white, grey) or to have it be team-colored.
That, and the grave just appearing seems a little flat. If it could shake and rise, kind of like the graves from Ghosts and Goblins, that'd be neat.

real ones dont even bother to add decay

Fuck alpha fade and decay
All my homies use alpha fade in random + alpha fade out random + lifespan decay
Also lookin good