@lunaduskjr It seems you're playing on an old version of The Gray Button. The older version of the mod required you to tap it on a specific time of the timer. Recently, the module got an update. I recommend verifying the integrity of game files (update your files) and re load the module.

The gray button manual does not seem to be correct, it claims you need to hold the button when you only need to press it when the distance matches the seconds positions

Stanley would be happy.

This is a comment. It has words.