duuuude... that was a SOUL-CATCHING experience
no words would describe how gorgeous the campaign was

9/10 love this map and key searching was fun. rng was fun too

to be honest it was boring and hard
i can't see anything, my eyes died.

The creator of this map had some trauma about keys. Probably lost it so many times so his mom refuse to let him home unless he found it. Such a miserable childhood. Please be compassionate. Amen.

Please make level 2 into two seperate levels. It is just too damn long for its own good. Otherwise, I really enjoy it. But jesus christ, that one level is too long. There is no reason for it to be that long. Especially when later levels are nowhere near as gargantuan. It's absurd.

This campaign is absolutely garbage.
Extremely open maps where you are going to find doors locked and have to find keys or keycards, but it's completely directionless, It's like the creator just made a map and decided to slap a bunch of locked doors and keys later. While playing with my party I can't name how many times we were lost or confused.
There are points in the game where it becomes almost completely dark, and others where there is a grain effect on screen that is honestly painful to the eyes. And to end it all, it is so LONG and ABSOLUTELY BORING. The illusions are as exciting and dense as a singular white piece of paper. The maps are bland and meaningless, and feels as seeing SH throughout the eyes of a child who only understands the significance of the game as "COOL AND EPIC ILLUSIONS/TRAUMA" or something like that, and I wouldn't be so annoyed by it if I hadn't have wasted 3 precious HOURS trying to get through it.
3/10 (And that's me being generous)

finding the keys even with noclip is a pain in the ass. anyone wanting to play should use the command warp_all_survivors_to_checkpoint to not spend hours looking for keys in foggy maps.

still pretty boring

没看攻略就打0分，看了攻略再打可以打满分

do not play this is map it is broken with errors and no guidance through the chapter the final is impossible due to too many spawns ( mainly tanks) if your a big fan of silent than play the original or left turn tribute to silent hill 3.

https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1727338367

https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2927231410

大便图。
第一关随机刷尸体开建筑门，地窖安全门竟然还要钥匙，安全门是刷新在一楼入口头顶门沿上，最恶心是你站二楼窗口看钥匙不显示，必须要走到门沿上才出现钥匙恶心坏了。第二关开始被杂物堵住的门现在是不可破坏的，就TM离谱，挂着寂静岭的ip粪图。
和寂静岭1复刻图真是高下立判

4.9/10

which difference with this collection? dont know which one to play https://psteamcommunity.yuanyoumao.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=2927231410

This map is such a boring slog. It's just not fun at all. 0/10

10/10.

0/10

最后你竟然让我睡好觉，还goodbye，我睡**，**

El mapa es innecesariamente largo y oscuro.

6.7/10

0分，找路找了一个小时，看攻略也看了，桥下什么玩偶也没用，找了半天找到了工人，然后去楼上又让找洞，直接破防了，第一关都没过去，不推荐

As a Silent Hill fan, I loved this map. Was really challenging. Lots of cool effects. If you haven't played Silent Hill, idk that you will understand or like this all that much. Nice work to the creator. Music top notch also.

这是一个很还原的好地图，当然没玩过寂静岭的人会觉得相当难受，可以理解，部分必要道具随机摆放，需要熟记地图，总体来说，对于寂静岭粉丝来说很有意思

0.0000000001/10

on chapter 2, use mat_fullbright 1 when you really can't see (RECOMMENDED). but yea turn off when u think u're good duh

nobody asked but i completed with bots only (just 3 bots and me). and yes I admit i used noclip at some map (not all, and I think I used about 3 times) when I really really really dk and got lost. don't be ashamed if yall used hack in this map, valid reaction btw.

idk but i guess good 8/10

i dont understand the ending

https://youtu.be/iFjd0oDc_Ig?si=1j25oruF5l94n0EF

如果有m属性可以玩一下 太tm难受了 跟个难嚼的黄糕一样已经给气死

Hate is a strong word, but this campaign, oh, this campaign. I do not recommend playing this, just go play the first Silent Hill campaign instead. Trust me, it is not worth a headache.

2/10
Time it took to complete: 3 hours, 29 minutes.

PROS
+ The scenery is nice in most maps
+ Custom Soundtrack
+ Not combined with other mods that can conflict unlike the original version

CONS
- Map design is very difficult to navigate in many aspects, including the city chapter and apartment chapter
- The keys. No indication of what they are, what they belong too, or any hint of where they could be. And even if the hint is there the map design makes it convoluted and frustrating to find the key you are looking for.
- The map is too dark in some chapters where you enter the other world.
- The finale is too bright and also feels incredibly out of place for a Silent Hill story.
- The hints (If any) are too subtle and difficult to figure out.

When replaying first map after a reset (teamwipe) Im receiving a flow error - director cant populate the world. If it is only me, you may ignore this comment. Unfortunately I believe it is common issue. I would like to see it fixed since speed running this map a lot. If needed I can contribute to the fix, just add me if you want to talk it over.

玩了这么多求生的地图第一次忍不了骂两句了，地图大归大，但实际上一点引导都没有，第三关更是从工厂到野外再到地洞一个安全门都没看到，第三关地图比作者他家的死亡记录本还长，好不容易进地洞了想救人结果全是铁丝网挡着，我甚至怀疑作者根本没有把救援的道路做出来让玩家看到救不到感受绝望，我承认作者这一点做的很好，那一刻我确实感受到了恐怖，重开跳关后更是没有一点引导全是雾气根本不知道往哪走，我不知道这个地图的受众到底是谁，可能只有抖m才会喜欢吧

10of10 , GREAT MAP

Garbage with 90% of gameplay that looks like "search for a key in giant city"

玩不下去

Would be cool if this got reworked into a more linear map design (using the same exact assists) for a more faithful l4d2 experience. still super ambitious campaign regardless!

You bastard!

所以？没有指引，没有线索？一张移植图还得玩原作？作者你送我游戏吗？
So? No guidance, no clues? A transplant map still has to play with the original? Author: Did you send me a game?

i will list this map on my suicide note

Conflict Files in RED

头一次创意工坊留言来骂一张地图，这死了妈的地图做的跟作者他妈的屄一样大，找完钥匙找钥匙卡来回找，最后一关还刷个charger恶心人。真他妈的弱智，看完我留言的真别玩这张图了，纯恶心人。

i'm not sure if its this version but it made a pick up sound when i pick items up my vpk file was the only one i had and when i removed it the sound stopped

worst campaign of all time - are you the deaf dumb and blind kid from pinball wizard or what, 0 excuses to release this schizo nightmare of a map

一张纯粹的屎图，一张脱离了低级趣味的屎图，它的存在告诉了我们品鉴hehe30真的不是什么难事。hehe30我好歹可以看晨晨整活，而这张屎图就是纯粹的找钥匙模拟器，让人忍不住想知道作者是如何做到拉出这么一张地图的，毕竟将地图做的这么又空又无聊真的不是随随便便就可以做到的。地图里面的小僵尸都成了濒危品种，你跑10分钟的图都不一定能遇见一个小僵尸，能让你乐呵乐呵开枪的机会都不多。总结，如果你闲的没事想浪费你人生中的两个半小时，然后带着一肚子憋屈离开的话，那就赶快下载吧，玩上这图这辈子有了。

非常好玩，建议图荒的都来玩

Damn, I remember playing this back in 2014? and it was ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ great. It's not a typical campaign tho coz you gotta find keys and ♥♥♥♥.

God this campaign is so terrible. The layout of some levels is so confusing and you barely see any supply during the levels.

managed to find the key easily below the bridge where it says "I wonder if that guy is still around", game crashed, now "that guy" is nowhere to be found, where else does he spawn?

too bloody dark can't see

司马地图，只会跑路和藏钥匙是吧，无提示跑半天告诉我要回头拿钥匙，你做你妈了个逼的图

nice map