An overall interesting design in this genre, and the first few hours will be pretty fun. However you'll find the repetition sets in rather quickly, along with a mostly lifeless world. Writers have done their best to create interesting scenarios and build a lovecraft inspired setting, but often times it's fairly disjointed.
While not an absolutely inspiring game, there's enjoyment to be had still, but it's fairly limiting. I would recommend the game at a budget price, but not neccessarily at full.

Terribly boring and repetitive gameplay loop. Doesn't really matter whether there's a fire, leak, man in the water, or general repairs, you just click one of your men to go there and it's all the same. Admittedly, the game has interesting elements, like closing distance to the other ship, different weapons and damage types, but it's just not enough and there is hardly any variation.