Sifted Sand takes 30 sand to make, and grants 1 random item from this list. It is a weighted table and is more likely to give trash/common items.

- Trash: Fish Bones, Soggy Paper, Old Bottle
- Common: Auger Shell, Orange Starfish, Red Starfish, Blue Sea-Glass, Green Sea-Glass, Sand Dollar, Mussel
- Uncommon: Conch Shell, Sharkeye Shell, Pink Starfish, Yellow Sea-Glass, Treasure Map Fragment, Clam, Oyster, Small Crab
- Rare: Whelk Shell, Blue Starfish, Purple Starfish, Pink Sea-Glass, Pink Coral, Golden Coin
- Very Rare: Purple Sea-Glass, Abalone