I've tamed, and spawned in all the creatures the cauldron has possible. I've used the pumpkin pie when needed. I can't seem to get the eye of dodo, or the tongue of cat. I've tried killing them but the dodo seems to just get bloody and never actually give me anything upon death. It just decomposes. The cat gives me nothing either. Am I missing something in the process?

I want to get the broom, and this is all that's stopping me. I LOVE this mod...it's a lot of fun.