When I saw that Athletic was disallowed I actually rolled my eyes a bit. The idea that all smokers are unable to do athletic is a bit of a stereotype. It's not healthy, but not everyone reacts to it the same way.

For instance, I have 2 friends who are healthier than me and probably most people who read this comment and they both smoke. One works on a fishing boat in Alaska and the other one runs triathalons.

Some people are simply built different I guess.

Doesnt wilderness expert already give you everything that herbalist does? I picked it instead of herbalist and my survivor was able to identify poisonous and edible forage food.

Thanks you so much!