thank you so much for this guide!! i have one question about the NG+ pumpkin charm listed here:
"-After 1 conversation with Harpae, as soon as you come out of the long stairs into the closed corridor, go all the way down when it's dark! Once you enter the library it will disappear."

i went all the way down and checked all over the entire corridor before ever entering the library and never saw anything, i even went all the way to the right where G says it's too dark to continue. am i missing something? otherwise thank you for the great guide!!

you actually don't need to find the secret room to get ending 4. I just got it nut haven't found the room yet

Btw for the woof, woof! achievement if you give Lisette someone's regalia she will be mad at you and you can get the achievement that way too.

Yes! There is pumpkin in that hole indeed I finally got it. Thank you so much for help

Hanging sweets in Fletas garden? Hmmm, i dont remember that one... I'll start another round

I'm pretty sure the pumpkin progress saves between playthroughs, because I got the achievement in Fleta's area on my 2nd playthrough.

But now that Avorin mentioned it, the pumpkin hiding in the bushes in Fleta's maze is a pretty hard one to find. The candy is near the entrance to the pumpkin king area.

Also, it's possible that you have to talk to all the pumpkins in one game, that would mean it's not enough to find those missing pumpkins in the next game if you haven't talked to all the pumpkins in that game. I'm not sure because I got the achievement on my first try, but it's possible.

Unfortunately, I don't think so because the achievement was bugged, you just missed one pumpkin. There are a lot of them in the game, so it's hard for me to tell which one you've passed. All I know is that there aren't that many pumpkins in the Lisette and Enjel area, there are a few at Harpae's, and they're on the 2nd and 3rd floors. I think somewhere at the beginning of the game or at Fleta's you might have lost something, because there are the most pumpkins.

@Loken Did you talk to that pumpkin that's hidden at the edge of the map in the left room by the red carpet? and also with all pumpkins after room change? there is also a pumpkin hidden in the bushes in the flute garden, you have to click on the hanging sweets to make the pumpkin show up. also talking to the pumpkin king and all the pumpkins around it counts. There's also one pumpkin in the forgotten attic right next to the door to the level exit, when you're running away it's probably the easiest pumpkin to miss, because if you run away you don't have time to talk to it.