This seems to be the equivalent of joe shmoe passing you by on the street and telling you CoD is the best game they've played and you def need to get it.
Which leads to my response: I don't know you, I don't know what you're about, so I don't want to know what you recommend because we most likely have very different tastes.

I imagine this is why so many are pissed off by this experiment 006.

Not to mention all the reviews I was given weren't even fully recommendations. They were half recommendations with caveats because there's no "meh" review option.

Steam community reviews work en masse because there's so many of them, you can get an idea, build a mental image of the situation using each review as a piece. Each review on it's own is meaningless, only together do they paint the full picture.
You're showing people a single pixel of the picture and telling them it's the full picture, which it isn't.