... My advice... respectfully... is to get better criteria those are good but should not make or break a game.

For shooters:
- Weapon design
- Bullet physics
- Weapon Mods
- Balance
- No microtrasactions

Online PVP:
- Balance
- Functioning anti-cheat
- Friend Functions
- Different game modes
- Ranked and unranked matches
- Fun
- No microtransactions

Story Based:
- Good story
- Compelling characters
- World/Level design
- No mircrotransactions

引用自 +archer+：

What makes a game for you perfect?

for me :
steam profiles can online be found
it is possible to chat with friends in game or in lobby
rank based system
a good anti cheat system

All it has to say on the box is RPG.

Edit: and not be Woke/D.E.I.

引用自 +archer+：

What makes a game for you perfect?

No such thing.

But "no online MP/no PvP" is a good start.

"Triggers the anti-woke sheep" is another.

Youtube shows how the game looks.

No such thing as a perfect game. But if a game isn't fun, it's not worth playing. Which is why I don't touch anything by Naughty Dog these days.

Enjoying the game, that's the criteria.

I play SP, not MP.

Great moment-to-moment gameplay. Alternatively, a really well thought-through web of problems & solutions (see Gothic 1 & 2).

引用自 +archer+：

What makes a game for you perfect?

for me :
steam profiles can online be found
it is possible to chat with friends in game or in lobby
rank based system
a good anti cheat system

A nice anti-cheat system is a bonus, if it's co-op then let the focus be on co-op and team play, good weapons that handle well with the option of a good sidearm, lots of things to kill or blow up, those make me happy

a fun experience