Complete Saga is a lot less buggy for one. There was more Lego charm and creativity put into the older games sadly. Both games cover the story of the movies but this one has more. It is really up to you but I recommend playing Complete Saga as it's less sidequest-y and somehow better put together lol.

if you want side quests, the ability to unlock hundreds of ships and characters through somewhat unique and engaging side missions, Skywalker the one for you.

clone wars is a good playthrough

Skywalker saga is full of all the good starwars references and memes, it's clear they have a lot of love for the starwars community. The old games are good for some nostalgia too, they follow different parts of the movies in different ways. I played starwars original trilogy DS before I saw any movies, and I think it's worth playing just because none of the other games do it the same. Also, what bugs did people run into? I didn't find any

That and some of the maps are a 1:1 conversion but look amazing even the textures on the plastic look so good I often stop and think "oh wow".

Simple. This game blows, Complete Saga is the gem that saved the sharty. This game is insanely dumbed-down, didn't even know you could do that to a Lego game.

引用自 AMAZING PAPERBOY DELIVERS!：

Simple. This game blows, Complete Saga is the gem that saved the sharty. This game is insanely dumbed-down, didn't even know you could do that to a Lego game.

this game isn't bad at all. I actually like some aspects of this game more than the old Lego Star Wars games. You are just hating on it because 1. You are bad at the game or get bored easily, or 2. The Complete Saga is just pure nostalgia for you and you believe it is the best and all others suck.

引用自 CoolCapybara13：

引用自 AMAZING PAPERBOY DELIVERS!：

Simple. This game blows, Complete Saga is the gem that saved the sharty. This game is insanely dumbed-down, didn't even know you could do that to a Lego game.

this game isn't bad at all. I actually like some aspects of this game more than the old Lego Star Wars games. You are just hating on it because 1. You are bad at the game or get bored easily, or 2. The Complete Saga is just pure nostalgia for you and you believe it is the best and all others suck.

You can't be "bad" at a game that consists of running down hallways and occasionally pressing button sequences that are spelled out for you and have no stakes. And I play slow-paced games all the time, this game is just obscenely boring because it tries to do a ton of stuff but no thought is put into any of it, you literally just walk to objective markers. If you enjoy this game, this might be up your alley:
https://psteamproxy.yuanyoumao.com/app/1144110/Open_World_Game_the_Open_World_Game/
And being nostalgic for a game doesn't suddenly mean my opinion is moot, Complete Saga is very obviously the better game here unless shiny-looking lighting effects and jokes that try way too hard are enough to convince you that the hallway simulator is better.

A C H I E V E M E N T S
( if you care at all about them... )

so the story is the same? does both follow the movie the exact same? or theres differences?

引用自 P0MK0NTHA1：

so the story is the same? does both follow the movie the exact same? or theres differences?

They're different. Complete Saga follows the first 6 films with no dialogue and using that to showcase gags and explain things through movement of what's happening. The Skywalker saga has the dialogue redone from all 9 main movies so it lines up with what happens with the films and even some added dialogue for the game. My favorite thing is they used Clone Wars actors for Kenobi and Anakin in the game. But they're very different even though they follow the same stories.

It's a completely different game but about the same subjects. Thought they did well to make the stages in Skywalker saga to be different from the ones that came out before. And the added planets and hub areas add in a bunch of side content and such.

Also, this game is NOT open world and people who say that have no idea what open world is.

引用自 Hotel Security：

It's a completely different game but about the same subjects. Thought they did well to make the stages in Skywalker saga to be different from the ones that came out before. And the added planets and hub areas add in a bunch of side content and such.

Also, this game is NOT open world and people who say that have no idea what open world is.

still, it has a much larger map than most other Lego games

Gameplay: 3rd person instead of top-down-view, shooter-like fighting
Story: Sequels included, Rey mistakenly portrayed as the center piece of the saga on the title screen
Level design: an open world connected by tiny levels instead of extensive levels connected by a semi open world
Performance: I ran into barely any bugs and no performance problems, which has never happened before in a Lego game on PC for me, Complete Saga as an older Lego game will likely have some

The first is definitely a good modernization of the formula, the second is controversial and a negative from my view, the third is in my opinion the wrong direction, because the focus should be on the story and not 140 fetch quests. The gameplay is just not (and shouldnt be given the target groups) diverse enough to stay interesting after a thousand repetitive riddles. Ive wrote more about it in my Steam review, I think you should be able to open it from my profile.
I personally prefer the Complete Saga, because it isnt artificially stretched, though it has been a long time since I played it on Wii, so there might be some nostalgia affecting my judgement.