Black Mesa is HELLA overrated. :: Black Mesa 综合讨论

商店页面

Black Mesa

全部讨论截图艺术作品实况直播视频创意工坊新闻指南评测

Black Mesa > 综合讨论 > 主题详情

Bílá Síla

8 月 24 日上午 10:00

Black Mesa is HELLA overrated.

I dont get why so many people brainlessly worship this so called remake like its a good game. Its not a good remake and as a game its mediocre at best. The enemies and weapon design are the biggest problem, no matter the difficulty the combat encounters are either super quick and easy or nearly impossibly infuriating. Many iconic weapons that were super stong in the original are now straight up useless. Mainly the RPG rockets that are slower than a slug and the crossbow that takes this long ass animation after each shot. Also there is a big problem with tau cannon which just goes true the enemy withou damaging it. The game is kinda fun until you get to the ironically named chapter- Black Mesa. This level is frustratingc claustrophobic maze where you have to fight tons of grunts and vortigaunts giving you no space to dogde or manouver. The game doesnt tell you in any way where to go and how to get there, You are just supposted to find all these stupid levers and buttons on your own. What a stupid game design. In combat you always get stuck on some random props lying on the floor, making you take damage. Also for some reason the game really starts to lag here. Every time you open some door that leads to a different segment of this map, or when the enemies spawn right in your face or an explosion goes off, the game freezes for a few seconds. Then it unfreezes and makes your camera face a completely different direction, making you take even more unnecessary damage. So unlike in the original, in this mediocre remake raw skill wont help you. And mind you im playing on a high end brand new PC. So yeah, its overrated af. Boring as hell. 3,5/10 at max is my rating.

< >

正在显示第 1 - 15 条，共 101 条留言

GuilometerSnickle 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 24 日上午 10:50

It's a high-quality game and it's really nice, but yes, there's a glaring issue due to the fact there's no HL:Gold Src charm. I'm talking the AI interactions, the weapons being fun, and maps being well-paced.

Now BM is still really neat and CC have done nothing to make it bad. But it doesn't meet what made HL:1 so good. I know it's also a re-imagining but it wouldn't harm BM at all to add a few intrinsic values and nuances from Half-Life.

I hope it's not against Valve's agreement with CC to modify/allow fans to have greater mod accessibility so we can access the AI to do those improvements ourselves.

edit: Also, not every game will run well on older/newer PC. If you are using Vulkan, it's fairly underdeveloped because of NVIDIA so it will provide better performance but inconsistency issues with lag spikes. Other games that have it don't even run at all with it... So it's great BM's actually operates even with issues.

最后由 GuilometerSnickle 编辑于; 8 月 24 日上午 10:52

Thornok

8 月 24 日上午 11:51

not everyone using nvidia

GuilometerSnickle 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 24 日下午 2:13

I didn't say using nvidia, just that they halted the progression of Vulkan in order to push forward their Phys x which they abandoned just recently with their current Graphics series. No replacement yet so they are very unperformed on physics games. Either way, Vulkan is inconsistent but is improving over-time. However staying away from the computers that cannot process even a single physics calculation for their value is paramount. Normal renders are still running strong as long as NVIDIA doesn't try to get them changed to push their products.

BurningCakeDoesAche 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 24 日下午 4:01

There is no chapter with the name "Black Mesa".

Eze

8 月 24 日下午 8:24

Now I know you don't listen to the characters, who heavily imply what you have to do next.

This is so made up.

CK❄BobbyScλrly❄ 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 24 日下午 10:08

引用自 iCUCKZ：
I dont get why so many people brainlessly worship this so called remake like its a good game. Its not a good remake and as a game its mediocre at best. The enemies and weapon design are the biggest problem, no matter the difficulty the combat encounters are either super quick and easy or nearly impossibly infuriating. Many iconic weapons that were super stong in the original are now straight up useless. Mainly the RPG rockets that are slower than a slug and the crossbow that takes this long ass animation after each shot. Also there is a big problem with tau cannon which just goes true the enemy withou damaging it. The game is kinda fun until you get to the ironically named chapter- Black Mesa. This level is frustratingc claustrophobic maze where you have to fight tons of grunts and vortigaunts giving you no space to dogde or manouver. The game doesnt tell you in any way where to go and how to get there, You are just supposted to find all these stupid levers and buttons on your own. What a stupid game design. In combat you always get stuck on some random props lying on the floor, making you take damage. Also for some reason the game really starts to lag here. Every time you open some door that leads to a different segment of this map, or when the enemies spawn right in your face or an explosion goes off, the game freezes for a few seconds. Then it unfreezes and makes your camera face a completely different direction, making you take even more unnecessary damage. So unlike in the original, in this mediocre remake raw skill wont help you. And mind you im playing on a high end brand new PC. So yeah, its overrated af. Boring as hell. 3,5/10 at max is my rating.

dude thats your opinion, since is remake they make different design, they can't make the same AI like half-life that will be ridiculous, then play half life if you didn't like black mesa.
BM is one of the best remakes from HL Universe, and is still the best one, still better than disaster from HL Source.
they're try to reimagine most stuff from HL1, but is impossible to make similar like HL1 since is different engines.

最后由 CK❄BobbyScλrly❄ 编辑于; 8 月 24 日下午 10:11

GuilometerSnickle 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 25 日下午 2:03

引用自 λG❄ScλrlyToga❄：
dude thats your opinion, since is remake they make different design, they can't make the same AI like half-life that will be ridiculous, then play half life if you didn't like black mesa.
BM is one of the best remakes from HL Universe, and is still the best one, still better than disaster from HL Source.
they're try to reimagine most stuff from HL1, but is impossible to make similar like HL1 since is different engines.

Actually, it's very possible to do. It's technically the same engine, just a updated improved branch that has rooted off into it's own tree-like. It's just CC didn't improve the AI at all aside from make them not use the exact same as HL:2 kinda sad tbh.

EasyC

8 月 26 日上午 12:14

Wall of text ignored.

BurningCakeDoesAche 拥有 Black Mesa

8 月 26 日上午 8:31

Why post this here anyway? Just drop a review. Going into the forums of a game and posting a negative opinion is just asking for people to be angry at you